| Year | Inductees (* Deceased) | Award |
|---|---|---|
| 1972 | James Fair | Player |
| 1973 | No Inductee | |
| 1974 | Robert Gladney* | Player, Manager |
| 1974 | Bobby Hallmark* | Player, Manager |
| 1975 | Glenn Rogers* | Player, Manager |
| 1976 | Leon Lester | Player |
| 1977 | Sammy Lane* | Leader, Player, Manager |
| 1977 | Pauline Woods | Leader, Player, Manager |
| 1978 | Gene E. Carr* | Leader, Player |
| 1978 | Charles Haney, Sr.* | Leader, Player, Manager |
| 1979 | No Inductee | |
| 1980 | No Inductee | |
| 1981 | John Oliver | Leader |
| 1982 | No Inductee | |
| 1983 | No Inductee | |
| 1984 | Garland Boren* | Player |
| 1984 | Joel Cook, Jr.* | Leader, Player, Manager |
| 1985 | Wallis Beaty* | Leader, Player, Manager |
| 1985 | Wesley Hargraves | Leader, Player, Manager |
| 1985 | John T. Jacobs | Leader, Player, Manager |
| 1985 | Larry W. Smith | Leader, Player |
| 1985 | Joe Ed Thompson | Leader, Player |
| 1986 | Mary Dartez* | Leader |
| 1986 | Sheri Mize | Manager |
| 1987 | No Inductee | |
| 1988 | David Armstrong* | Player, Manager |
| 1989 | Robert F. Stevens | Leader, Player, Manager |
| 1990 | Robert Easley | Leader |
| 1990 | Pauline Laster | Leader, Player, Manager |
| 1990 | Charles Neil | Leader, Player, Manager |
| 1990 | Mary Jo Stevens | Leader, Player, Manager |
| 1990 | Sam WIlliamson | Leader, Player, Manager |
| 1991 | Gerald Bryant | Leader, Player, Manager |
| 1992 | Robert Arnold | Player |
| 1992 | Zelma Cubello | Leader, Player, Manager |
| 1992 | Sammy Oates* | Player |
| 1993 | Allen Dove | Leader, Player |
| 1993 | Mary J. Eddleman | Player |
| 1994 | Jack Giacona | Player, Manager |
| 1994 | Dale Frankenhauser | Player |
| 1995 | Juan Carrizales Jr | Player |
| 1996 | Glenn Deville* | Leader, Manager |
| 1997 | No Inductee | |
| 1998 | No Inductee | |
| 1999 | Glenna Cooper | Leader, Player |
| 2000 | Cleve Cormier | Leader |
| 2000 | Tom Fischer | Old Time Player |
| 2000 | Edward Ketchum* | Old Time Player |
| 2000 | Carol Robinson | Player |
| 2001 | No Inductee | |
| 2002 | Pedro Gomez | Player |
| 2002 | Don Adkin* | Old Time Player, Manager |
| 2002 | Katie Van Dusen | Player |
| 2002 | Robert Brannan | Leader |
| 2003 | Wayne Carter | Player |
| 2003 | Rickie Boutte* | Player |
| 2003 | Rita Reneau | Player |
| 2004 | Janet Simmons | Player |
| 2004 | Charles Martin | Player |
| 2005 | Larry Fewell | Player |
| 2005 | Tony Ramirez | Player |
| 2005 | Marla Ratcliff | Player |
| 2006 | Buddy Van Dusen | Player |
| 2006 | Paul F. Jakins | Old TIme Player |
| 2006 | James Garrett | Player |
| 2006 | Patricia Henderson | Leader |
| 2007 | Al Jordan* | Player |
| 2007 | Henry E. Harvard | Player |
| 2007 | Jens Williamson, III | Old Time Player |
| 2008 | Daryl Argrave | Player |
| 2008 | Thelma Covello | Leader |
| 2008 | Nick Imme | Old Time Player |
| 2009 | Terry Newsome | Old Time Player |
| 2010 | No Inductee | |
| 2011 | No Inductee | |
| 2012 | Luther Green | Player |
| 2012 | Susan Lefors | Old Time Player |
| 2012 | Lanny Pickering | Leader |
| 2013 | No Inductee | |
| 2014 | Bobby Wilbanks | Old Time Player |
| 2014 | Scott Williams | Player |
| 2014 | Frank Allnutt | Player |
| 2014 | Christina Ruberry | Player |
| 2014 | Wanda Rayner | Player |
| 2015 | Luann Buckhalter-Mills | Player |
| 2015 | Jesse Carrizales | Player |
| 2015 | David Howell | Player |
| 2015 | Mark Phillips | Player |
| 2015 | Bobbie Bridges-Scoggins | Player |
| 2016 | Debra Kyle | Player |
| 2016 | Lenora Brewster | Player |
| 2016 | Dan Arabie | Player |
| 2016 | Jill Jordan | Player |
| 2016 | Jennifer Gaskin | Player |
| 2017 | Ken Seabolt | Player |
| 2017 | Donna Fine | Leader, Player |
| 2017 | Johnny Courtright | Player |
| 2017 | Jessica McMahon | Player |
| 2017 | Kevin Sowards | Player, Manager |
| 2017 | Jerilyn Keller | Player |
| 2017 | Suzanne Vage | Player |
| 2017 | Randy Roberts | Player |
| 2017 | Brent Ketchum | Player |
| 2017 | Tommy Varner | Player |
| 2017 | Debbie Sisley | Player |
| 2018 | Mike Landry | Player |
| 2018 | David Lefors | Player |
| 2018 | Vanessa Hopkins | Player |
| 2019 | James Kelly | Player |
| 2019 | Robert Wise | Player |
| 2019 | Kent Reneau | Player |
| 2021 | Scott Allen | Player |
| 2021 | Cindy Robillard | Manager |
| 2021 | Gerald Bamburg | Player |
| 2021 | Jimmy Semons | Player |
| 2021 | Lori Rojas | Player |
| 2022 | Erin Cazedessus | Player |
| 2022 | Larry Young | Player |
| 2022 | Luis Salgado | |
| 2023 | Henrietta Ingram | Player |
| 2023 | Jason Wynne | Player |
| 2023 | James Davis | Player |
| 2023 | Roy Willis | Player |
| 2024 | Gina Massie | Leader |
| 2024 | Davida Webster | Player |
| 2024 | Robbye McGilvery | Player |
| 2024 | Candace Sexton-Ruiz | Player |
| 2024 | Amanda Richards | Player |